Genderist MSPs must stop indulging in ideologically-driven, law-defying nonsense
The zealotry no longer washes - gender self-ID is the stupidest ideology of our times
.jpeg?trim=0,4,0,0&crop=&width=640&quality=70&enable=upscale)

‘The problem with the world,’ according to the adage attributed to Charles Bukowski, ‘is that intelligent people are full of doubts, while stupid ones are full of confidence.’
Intelligent people do not remain doubtful on matters of importance forever, of course. People being stupid about something can likewise find humility after facing competent opponents.
Stupid ideas, however, are capable of causing absolute carnage, particularly if powerful people – often otherwise intelligent – internalise falsehoods and refuse any further discussion.
Gender self-ID is the stupidest, most powerful ideology I’ve watched manifest in my lifetime.
In short: it demands the category of ‘woman’ includes men who claim a ‘female identity’ and vice-versa. All must comply with this unquestioningly or suffer severe consequences.
I’m presuming, this long into this sorriest of sagas, that most are well aware of the various problems this has caused. Suffice to say it’s been as chaos-inducing as trying to run the world according to the belief 2+2=3. It’s slowly rooted in all cultural and political institutions, our schools, the NHS, and even parts of the judiciary. It’s a wild set of reality-denying ideas that’s proving as stubbornly indestructible as Japanese knotweed.
It’s purely down to the confidence and intelligence of women who have opposed its excesses this past decade that it’s now far easier to have necessary discussions about repairing and healing from the havoc it has unleashed.
Which brings me to the welcome appearance of three intelligent, knowledgeable, and articulate women’s rights campaigners who gave evidence to the Scottish Parliament’s Equalities committee last Thursday: Susan Smith of For Women Scotland, Maya Forstater of Sex Matters, and Mary Howden of the Women’s Rights Network.
Questioning them, amongst other committee members, were two deeply hostile MSPs who, if at all self-aware, must now reflect – after their foolishness met wisdom – how wrong they’ve been about women’s rights and the law.
Should they not do so, they will continue to beclown themselves whenever matters of sex-based rights versus ‘gender-identity’ are raised, which, much to our collective exhaustion, they absolutely will be.
Holly Bruce and Kate Nevens MSPs, both of the Scottish Greens, currently remain ardent gender-identity believers. When followed to its logical conclusions, this ideology demands adherents say the most astonishingly foolish things. Both demonstrated this at the committee meeting.


Bruce, questioning Adam Jobson of the Scottish Prison Service, expressed concerns about the wellbeing of ‘those women’ recently transferred from female prisons to the male estate.
She was referring to, amongst others, male murderers and violent criminals who claim a ‘female identity’ and – until very recently – had been housed with often extremely vulnerable incarcerated women on that basis.
Before For Women Scotland took the Scottish government to task – and court, repeatedly – to address this egregiously dangerous, unlawful situation, female prisoners reported being predated on, threatened, and psychologically terrorised by some of these men.
But gender-identity zealotry demands men must be referred to as women if they desire it, no matter their motivation for such a claim. Bruce, with all the charm of a prim disciplinarian Head Prefect, later attempted to challenge Maya Forstater to provide any examples of ‘men’ trying to enter women’s spaces, as if this is not a well-known fact, and precisely the root of this enduring madness.
Having studied the excesses of genderist orthodoxy for years now, I suggest Bruce derives genuine pleasure from knowing how annoying she’s being. The smugness of the challenge, the goading to say ‘um, they’re men actually’ is a hangover from the ‘No Debate’ days where women were living in genuine terror at times of being pegged as one of those bad, ‘bigoted’, meanie ‘trans-exclusionary’ women.
But now, Bruce’s zealotry simply doesn’t wash. Once you terrorise enough women for having perfectly ordinary views based on material and legal reality, many more say ‘sod this’ and find the courage to speak out.
Forstater responded with the kindest smile and chuckle she could manage at Bruce’s ridiculous suggestion no men have been riding roughshod over women’s boundaries, meeting the haughty, sneering challenge by saying Bruce and she were effectively operating in different realities. Hers – Forstater’s – is the one that aligns with the law.
The point of the committee meeting was to discuss implementation of the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s updated Code of Practice for the provision of services, following FWS’s win at the Supreme Court last year. This clarified just how wrong many services have been to listen to genderist organisations like the largely government-funded Equality Network, which has pushed for the law to be misinterpreted for over a decade.
Defying Bukowski’s quote about stupid people’s confidence, a flustering Kate Nevens also tried to assert her own genderist falsities into proceedings. In a lengthy question she had to read from her laptop, she claimed women’s services which have been ‘trans-inclusive for decades’ were finding the code ‘unworkable’. How did the panel feel given such services were expending time and resources to change how they operate to exclude ‘trans women’? (For clarity: men.)
Absolute cobblers, of course, as Smith – more politely than I’ve just been – explained. Most truly women-focused organisations have long operated single-sex services, but have latterly been doing so in fear. They’re therefore ‘delighted’ the code allows them to say boldly: women only, on the basis of sex, as they were set up to be.
Nevens squirmed uncomfortably after Smith’s response. Being mid-40s like me, perhaps she suddenly remembered – however dimly – the first three decades of our lives where the definition of ‘woman’ wasn’t remotely under discussion?
Regardless, both she and Bruce would do well to listen to their elders, and cease indulging in ideologically-driven, law-defying nonsense. Any intelligent person watching their embarrassing performance would advise likewise. It’s unedifying for any legislator, and utter stupidity on stilts.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.
